Jurgen Klinsmann must be one of the luckiest SOBs to walk the Earth. Just when
his latest fit of message-sending resulted in Landon Donovan being frozen out of the US national team -- a team that includes the non-playing
Michael Parkhurst, Brek Shea and Stuart Holden, among others -- and threatened to overshadow the run-up to three crucial World Cup qualifiers, a shoe that's been levitating since Major League Soccer's inception in 1996 finally dropped.
MLS commissioner Don Garber achieved one of his
longest-held goals on Tuesday as English club Manchester City and the New York Yankees
announced they had agreed to create an MLS franchise that will play in New York City starting in 2015. America's top-flight soccer league already has a team in the area in the form of the New York Red Bulls, but NYRB plays well outside the city in Harrison, New Jersey, and has struggled to attract fans despite a glittering new stadium and several high-profile signings. Having long coveted a team located in the Five Boroughs that can draw on the city's ample ranks of soccer fans, Garber and MLS have their wish.
There are still issues to resolve, of course, with one of the most pressing being where New York City FC (NYCFC to its friends) will play.
A proposed stadium in Queens
faces continued resistance from both local groups -- who oppose handing over more public parkland on which the stadium will be built -- and the New York Mets -- who want more than $40 million in compensation in exchange for allowing people attending NYCFC games to use the parking lots at Citi Field. Manchester City (whose ownership group is led by Sheik Mansour, a member of the Abu Dhabi royal family) and the Yankees already face a $100 million expansion fee to join MLS, and replacing the parkland and soccer fields taken up by NYCFC's new home will heap an estimated $90 million on top of any costs incurred in building the stadium. Then there's the not-inconsiderable task of navigating the murky world of New York politics, a process that vexed even well-known entities like the Yankees and Mets as they tried to secure new stadiums.
To build a home for the team, the city, the league, Manchester City and
now the Yankees must win over half a dozen community boards, the city
planning commission, the City Council, and potentially state and federal
agencies — a process that will take months, if not years. Some of the
constituents oppose ceding parkland to a foreign billionaire.
“We’re not even talking about an American businessman who made shrewd
investments,” said Peter Vallone Jr., a city councilman from Astoria.
“We’re talking about a sheik born with a silver spoon in his mouth, and
we don’t need to hand him parkland on a silver platter.”
Getting big projects built in New York can take years, especially sports
sites that often become fodder for critics of the use of public
resources for wealthy team owners. The Mets and the Yankees each spent
nearly a decade lobbying for tax breaks and public subsidies before they
poured a combined $2.3 billion into their new stadiums, which opened in
2009.
It's perfectly understandable for people in Queens and the surrounding area to be wary of the NYCFC stadium landing in their back yard. The funding for these kind of projects almost invariably comes partially (if not wholly)
from public money, an extravagance that's
hard to justify amid a faltering economic recovery and persistent unemployment. There's the problem of the city appearing to hand a sweetheart deal to a baseball franchise
valued at $2.3 billion and a soccer club whose owner's
pockets are so deep they make the Mariana Trench look like a wagon rut. Then there are those in New York who are outraged that the city and MLS are doing business with a group that has such
close ties to Abu Dhabi, citing concerns about the emirate's human rights record and continuing ban on homosexuality. Workers' rights are
a bone of contention in that part of the world, especially with Qatar receiving the 2022 World Cup and Abu Dhabi and Dubai enjoying rising influence on the club level.
More interesting, though, is the
reaction from MLS supporters. There is the expected pushback from Red Bulls fans, but there also appears to be
a line of thinking that NYCFC's arrival is somehow bad for MLS. That may sound silly, and it could certainly be so, but there is also a kernel of truth that's worth exploring.